Federal judge issues criminal referral to Apple executive for apparent falsehoods

Apple's exec faces criminal referral for false testimony.

: A federal judge has referred Apple executive Alex Roman for criminal contempt proceedings, citing false testimony related to a commission decision. Epic Games' lawsuit, challenging Apple's monopoly, has led to this major development that highlights Apple's ongoing antitrust issues. The court criticized Apple's violation of an injunction and introduced fees that defied the ruling. Tim Sweeney from Epic celebrated the decision, indicating Epic's partial victory in their legal battle.

In a significant development, United States District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers issued a criminal referral against Apple executive Alex Roman for apparent falsehoods given under oath. This move pertains to Apple's decision to impose a new 27% fee on developers for purchases outside its App Store, an act that was seen as a violation of a previous court injunction. Epic Games, known for its Fortnite game, had launched a legal battle against Apple for its in-app purchase policies, which required a 30% commission.

The legal saga involving Epic Games and Apple started when Epic initiated 'Project Liberty'. This project aimed to challenge what it and other developers saw as Apple's unfair App Store practices. However, in a ruling largely in Apple's favor in 2021, Judge Gonzalez Rogers ordered Epic to compensate Apple for lost revenue but mandated Apple to permit developers to use alternative payment methods. The recent criminal referral is tied to allegations that Roman and other Apple executives did not accurately testify about the timeline related to the new commission fee, which Apple claimed was only decided in 2024, though documents indicate otherwise.

Tim Cook, Apple's CEO, reportedly ignored the advice of another senior executive, Phillip Schiller, when implementing the controversial new fee. Judge Gonzalez Rogers noted that Tim Cook's decision exacerbated Apple's non-compliance with the injunction. She has expressed no tolerance for any further delays in delivering justice and actions aligning with her court order. On X, Tim Sweeney, CEO of Epic Games, expressed contentment over the judge's ruling, indicating a major step forward in Epic's fight against Apple's 'junk fees'.

Tim Sweeney's statement emphasized the broader implications of the court's decision, noting the global nature of the verdict, thus increasing pressure on Apple to reconsider its stringent App Store policies. He offered a conciliatory note by proposing that if Apple applied the court’s judgment worldwide, Epic would revert Fortnite to the App Store.

As the legal repercussions unfold, this situation underlines important themes in the technology and gaming sectors: competition enforcement, corporate ethics, and the balance of power between platform owners and developers. The outcome of these developments is closely watched by other tech companies that may face similar scrutiny. It emphasizes the essential need for transparency and compliance in corporate governance.

Sources: Gizmodo, The New York Times, BBC News

gaming