Google threatened tech influencers unless they ‘preferred’ the Pixel
Google pressured influencers to promote the Pixel 9 over rivals or leave Team Pixel, later admitting the language was inappropriate.
Google's exclusive Team Pixel program, which provides early access to Pixel devices for influencers, enforced new terms that required participants to showcase the Pixel 9 over any competing devices. The stipulation posed a dilemma for tech reviewers, forcing them to choose between access to Google's latest technology and their professional integrity. Screenshots of this clause, independently verified by The Verge, caused a significant backlash among influencers on social media platforms like X and Threads.
Google's communication manager, Kayla Geier, clarified that the Team Pixel program is distinct from its press and official review programs; however, the new terms confused many into thinking all reviewers were affected. Influencers like Adam Matlock and Kevin Nether have since left the program, citing the unreasonable demands and the threat to their credibility and professional practices. The controversy highlights the ethical grey areas in tech reviews and Google's approach to influencer collaborations.
Despite the uproar, Google claims that the problematic clause has been removed. Still, this incident sheds light on the complexities and ethical challenges of influencer marketing in tech. Furthermore, it underscores the distinctions between influencer-led promotions and traditional, unbiased product reviews in maintaining transparency and trust with consumers.