Jack Dorsey and Elon Musk would like to ‘delete all Intellectual Property law’

Dorsey and Musk call for a radical shift in IP laws amid AI copyright debates.

: Jack Dorsey and Elon Musk advocate for the abolition of intellectual property laws, sparking intense debate on social media. Amidst current legal challenges faced by AI companies, Dorsey argues that existing systems only benefit gatekeepers rather than creators. Musk supports this position, consistent with his past views against patent enforcement, particularly noting Tesla's stance on patents. The conversation reflects a broader tension between tech leaders and the structures that protect creative works and their originators.

Jack Dorsey, Twitter's co-founder, and Elon Musk, who currently owns X, propose eliminating all intellectual property laws. They commented amidst ongoing lawsuits against AI firms like OpenAI, accusing them of copyright violations. Dorsey viewed current IP systems as rent-seeking entities that limit creativity, advocating for better models to compensate creators. Meanwhile, Musk's disdain for patents aligns with past actions where Tesla pledged not enforcing patents unless others used them dishonestly.

Their statements drew criticism and support. For instance, tech evangelist Chris Messina saw merit, given potential unfair penalties AI might face regarding intellectual property. In contrast, Ed Newton-Rex, who certifies AI practices, viewed their proposal as an attack on creators' rights. Writer Lincoln Michel criticized both, asserting their companies rely heavily on IP laws.

Dorsey later articulated his stance against monopolized artist payments, suggesting creativity distinguishes human creations from AI. His conversation with attorney Nicole Shanahan emphasized that IP law separates human from AI creations. Shanahan, opposing the removal, recommended reforming rather than eliminating current systems.

Musk's anti-patent sentiments appeared in past interviews, such as with Jay Leno, labeling patents as weaknesses, and through his 'patent giveaway' for Tesla. Funnily, Tesla did end up in a patent lawsuit, but this was termed as a counteraction to an original suit against them.

The dialogue between Dorsey and Musk illustrates diminishing barriers between online discussions and policy-making. Musk's involvement in the Trump administration and actions like mass layoffs through a meme-inspired government body indicate this trend.

Sources: The Verge, Twitter Posts, Medium by Lincoln Michel, Bluesky News

Technologyinnovation