Spotify tries to defend its artist payout rates

Spotify defends its artist payouts amid criticisms, especially compared to Apple Music.

: Spotify has released its annual Loud & Clear report, claiming to have paid artists $10 billion in 2024 and $60 million since launching. However, a Duetti report highlights lower payment rates per 1,000 streams on Spotify compared to other platforms, raising concerns among songwriters and artists. Furthermore, songwriters like Jesse Jo Dillon and Amy Allen criticize Spotify's subscription tiers for combining audiobooks and songs, affecting their earnings. Despite asserting significant payout increases over the past decade, Spotify faces challenges in maintaining goodwill with the artist community.

Spotify has published its annual Loud & Clear report, aiming to address ongoing criticisms about its artist payout rates. According to Spotify, artists received a total of $10 billion in 2024. Cumulatively, since its launch, Spotify claims to have paid $60 million to artists. In addition to these overarching figures, the company highlights that their payouts have increased tenfold over the past decade. Specifically, Spotify illustrates this growth by showing that the 100,000th most streamed artist saw earnings grow from $600 a decade ago to $6,000 in 2024. Similarly, the 10,000th most-streamed artist received $131,000 in 2024, compared to $34,000 ten years ago. Moreover, Spotify reports that nearly 1,500 artists have surpassed $1 million in earnings. Despite these eye-catching figures, Spotify continues to contend with skepticism and dissatisfaction from the artist community. A report from music catalog buyer Duetti has shed light on Spotify's per-stream payout rate, which in 2024 was approximately $3 per 1,000 streams. This figure pales in comparison to other major platforms, with YouTube offering $4.80, Apple Music $6.20, and Amazon Music $8.80 per the same number of streams. The Duetti report suggests discrepancies between Spotify's reported success and the reality experienced by many artists. Seemingly unfazed by these criticisms, Spotify has labeled these claims as 'ridiculous and unfounded,' insisting the streaming industry does not directly pay artists per stream. Within the world of streaming, this remains a hotly debated topic as platforms navigate complex relationships with artists.

Spotify's challenges with artist relations have practical repercussions as well. Earlier this year, Billboard reported that Spotify faced an unwelcome storm when four out of five artists nominated for songwriter of the year at the Grammys opted to skip Spotify's Grammy party for songwriters. Although the official reason for canceling Spotify's Grammy festivities was the impact of the Los Angeles wildfires, the artists' decision shone a spotlight on tensions within the music community. Influential songwriters like Jesse Jo Dillon and Amy Allen have criticized Spotify's decision to bundle audiobooks with music in certain subscription tiers. According to Dillon and Allen, this bundling move led to a significant financial impact: a loss of an estimated $150 million in US mechanical royalties in the first year stemming from the revised bundle rates.

Spotify has advocated for its business model by presenting several data points about its monetary policies, while at the same time dismissing claims of low per-stream payouts. Still, the comparisons with rival platforms offer a more nuanced picture that questions the streaming giant's financial valuation of artists' work. In its transparency efforts, Spotify underscores a concerted attempt to improve artist engagement and transparency regarding the platform's economic framework. The company hopes that increased clarity will help remedy long-standing perceptions among artists and the public.

All of these discussions can overshadow the broader conversation about the value of creative labor in a digitally-driven economy. Streaming platforms like Spotify, YouTube, Apple Music, and Amazon Music walk a fine line in balancing fair artist compensation with operational sustainability and innovation. This dance, however, does not excuse often unintended consequences seen in royalty calculations and perceptions of fairness within the music industry.

While Spotify's narrative positions the platform as a true champion of artists in the digital age, the ongoing conversations and reported experiences of musicians reflect a complex ecosystem that continuously pressures the company to reinvent and improve its relations with artists.

Sources: Engadget, TechCrunch, Billboard, Duetti

MusicstreamingSpotify