‘The Old Guard 2’ is a tender follow-up stretched thin by sequel syndrome

Netflix's 'The Old Guard 2' by Charlize Theron falls into sequel syndrome, focusing more on franchise than resolution.

: Featuring Charlize Theron and Uma Thurman, Netflix’s 'The Old Guard 2', directed by Victoria Mahoney, is a delayed sequel that struggles under narrative expectations. The plot centers on Andy’s (Theron) battle against a new threat, Discord (Thurman), amidst personal turmoil and the challenge of immortality. Despite its promise of showdown action, the film suffers from disjointed editing and lack of emotional depth, resulting in an unsatisfying and fragmented narrative. Critics point out how the movie serves more as a setup for future installments without delivering a compelling story.

“The Old Guard 2,” directed by Victoria Mahoney, continues the story of Andy (Charlize Theron) and her immortal team as they face new global threats. The sequel, which was delayed by industry strikes and Netflix’s production shifts, is set to premiere on July 2, 2025. Rated R for intense violence, it explores deeper emotional arcs, particularly Andy’s struggle with her newfound mortality and Nile’s growth into immortality.

Critics have described the film as a heartfelt continuation that suffers from “sequel syndrome”—trying to do too much while setting up future installments. The plot focuses on Quynh’s desire for revenge and the team’s efforts to understand their powers through Tuah, a new character played by Henry Golding. Emotional stakes are elevated, but some narrative elements feel overstuffed.

The trailer teases a dramatic confrontation between Andy and the franchise’s first immortal, played by Uma Thurman. Armed with a katana, Thurman’s character presents a lethal threat, especially now that Andy is no longer immortal. This climactic showdown adds intensity and raises the stakes beyond the original film.

Production faced setbacks, including a fire at Cinecittà studios and post-production delays. Despite this, Theron and the returning cast remained committed, with Theron stating she only returned because she believed they could make the sequel even better. The transition from original director Gina Prince-Bythewood to Mahoney also introduced a fresh creative tone.

While some reviewers warn of overextension in balancing character work and franchise expansion, the film is still expected to appeal to fans of the original and the graphic novel source material. The blend of action, emotion, and lore expansion offers just enough to carry the legacy forward.

Sources: Gizmodo, Netflix Tudum, ComicBookMovie, OneCutReviews

MoviesstreamingSequels